Reply to New Topic

Arantor

  • As powerful as possible, as complex as necessary.
  • Messages: 14 278
Reply to New Topic
« le 8 Février 2013 à 19:22 »
I came across Discourse recently; it's a forum built on Ruby on Rails, and I described it as the bastard lovechild of Vanilla and Google Wave. This is not a good thing.

But it does have some interesting ideas, most interestingly for me, it has 'Reply to New Topic'.

The idea is that you can hit the reply button, leaving a reference back to the original topic (e.g. as a quote or link) but essentially convert what would otherwise be an off-topic tangent into a new topic.

It's one method of keeping things on topic in what is essentially a flat topic model like we have.

Thoughts?
When we unite against a common enemy that attacks our ethos, it nurtures group solidarity. Trolls are sensational, yes, but we keep everyone honest. | Game Memorial

spoogs

  • Messages: 417
Stick a fork in it SMF

Dismal Shadow

  • Madman in a Box
  • Me: Who is Arantor? Cleverbot: It stands for time and relative dimensions in space.
  • Messages: 1 185
Re: Reply to New Topic
« Réponse #2, le 9 Février 2013 à 00:48 »
I stopped reading at "Google Wave". :P
“I will stand on my ground as an atheist until your god shows up...If my irreligious bothers you much, and if you think everything I do is heresy to your god I don't care. Heresy is for those who believe, I don't. So, it isn't heresy at all!


   Jack in, Wedge,
   EXECUTE!

Arantor

  • As powerful as possible, as complex as necessary.
  • Messages: 14 278
Re: Reply to New Topic
« Réponse #3, le 16 Février 2013 à 21:43 »
So. Anyway.

Reply to new topic (leaving a post behind the old topic, maybe)... or even quote to new topic. Thoughts?

Dismal Shadow

  • Madman in a Box
  • Me: Who is Arantor? Cleverbot: It stands for time and relative dimensions in space.
  • Messages: 1 185
Re: Reply to New Topic
« Réponse #4, le 17 Février 2013 à 00:47 »
Even the locked topic? What happens if you hit the reply button, leaving a reference back to the original topic that are locked?

Arantor

  • As powerful as possible, as complex as necessary.
  • Messages: 14 278
Re: Reply to New Topic
« Réponse #5, le 17 Février 2013 à 01:21 »
I'd be inclined to disallow reply-to-new-topic in that situation. If you want to reply and make it a new topic, just make it a new topic. Otherwise it's encouraging people to continue discussions that were locked for a reason.

MultiformeIngegno

  • Messages: 1 337
Re: Reply to New Topic
« Réponse #6, le 22 Février 2013 à 13:08 »
Uhm, could be a nice idea.. problem is: if you have good users it's useful because they'd do a part of the moderation for you; but if you have noob users or not so good users it can result in a lot of new topics without much reasons. I'd suggest to set permissions to admin and mod by default (then can be added to other groups by the admin of course).