Plugin Manager: Mechanics

Online Arantor

  • Wedgeward
  • Posts: 10,364
  • The Twelve Tasks of Asterix is awesome.
    • View profile
    • Innovate, not Imitate
Re: Plugin Manager: Mechanics
« Reply #45 on February 9th, 12:18 PM »
Yes, it's the same as SMF, basically, and it's a large contributing factor to why WP gets hacked quite often.
   computer-aided
   community building
             

Other stuff:

Online Nao

  • Wedgeward
  • Posts: 10,275
  • Reality check: I just discovered that Wedge already has a 'Mark unread' button for PMs, a feature in my to-do. Uh. It just isn't in the 'right' place...
    • View profile
    • Cynacittà @ noisen
Re: Plugin Manager: Mechanics
« Reply #46 on February 9th, 12:29 PM »
Quote from MultiformeIngegno on February 9th, 12:17 PM
I know you guys don't like Wordpress much
I don't mind WP, personally. If anything, the very fact that it's widespread means that it got something right... Maybe not in the code, but at least in its community handling.
  I say Wedge Wedge (in the butt)
« Everyone knows rock attained perfection in 1974. It's a scientific fact. » (Homer Simpson)

Online Arantor

  • Wedgeward
  • Posts: 10,364
  • The Twelve Tasks of Asterix is awesome.
    • View profile
    • Innovate, not Imitate
Re: Plugin Manager: Mechanics
« Reply #47 on February 9th, 12:41 PM »
Bear in mind it's about 9 years old now, it's pretty much the oldest PHP blogging platform, and it's still going, and its versatility with themes doesn't hurt it either.

(How many other blogging platforms running on PHP can you name?)
   computer-aided
   community building
             

Other stuff:

Offline MultiformeIngegno

  • Friends
  • Posts: 804
  • I have the tickets for the Coldplay live in Turin!!!!! :D
    • View profile
    • multiformeingegno
Re: Plugin Manager: Mechanics
« Reply #48 on February 9th, 01:44 PM »
IMHO one of its driving forces is that it's extremely flexible. It's not just a blogging platform, it's a CMS (okay, not a forum software, but a good CMS). Check out the custom template feature (90% like SSI.php), you can use WP to replace Joomla, it can be used in websites where you need to handle a lot of pages and people contribution..

I shouldn't care about security, I'd just add a 128px text (okay, maybe a little smaller :P) saying that if they're under a shared hosting and they use the web interface to upload & install stuff, they are at risk..

Why penalize users that know what they're doing (and maybe aren't on a shared hosting..)?
RockCiclopedia (wiki - forum - extra)
Tutta la storia del rock, scritta da voi ...

Online Arantor

  • Wedgeward
  • Posts: 10,364
  • The Twelve Tasks of Asterix is awesome.
    • View profile
    • Innovate, not Imitate
Re: Plugin Manager: Mechanics
« Reply #49 on February 9th, 01:55 PM »
Oh please. Calling it a CMS is like calling a go-kart a car. Both do the same job but one is a shabbily built, usable but neither efficient or elegant. Or it's like comparing a basic Nokia handset to an iPhone because they can both make calls when you want more than just calling functionality.

Quote
Check out the custom template feature (90% like SSI.php)
It's nothing like SSI.php except vaguely conceptually.

Quote
it can be used in websites where you need to handle a lot of pages and people contribution..
Not without significant work.

OK, I'm going to reiterate a point that I think has been forgotten.

I'm not bashing WP based on what I've seen. I USE WP CURRENTLY ON TWO SITES. I know exactly what it's capable of. Anything beyond a basic blog, it just can't handle. You cannot even have a page that's visible to signed in members only without *custom coding*, and not trivial custom coding, to boot. That alone rules it out of being a good CMS.

Quote
I shouldn't care about security
So when users get hacked, I can send them your way, can I? Because you know if a Wedge install gets hacked, they feel it's our fault first and foremost and never theirs.

Quote
saying that if they're under a shared hosting and they use the web interface to upload & install stuff, they are at risk..
Most users do not understand what shared hosting means. And they won't listen to that warning, they'll upload and install stuff regardless - but it'll be our fault when the shit hits the fan because "[Wedge] should have prevented there being a problem" and anything else is making excuses.

There's no best answer, only a selection of varyingly-bad answers, and right now I'm just sensing that not having an upload feature (like, I'll note, XenForo and quite probably vBulletin, though I haven't used it) is actually the lesser evil.
   computer-aided
   community building
             

Other stuff: